Community Forum Archive

The Epilepsy Community Forums are closed, and the information is archived. The content in this section may not be current or apply to all situations. In addition, forum questions and responses include information and content that has been generated by epilepsy community members. This content is not moderated. The information on these pages should not be substituted for medical advice from a healthcare provider. Experiences with epilepsy can vary greatly on an individual basis. Please contact your doctor or medical team if you have any questions about your situation. For more information, learn about epilepsy or visit our resources section.

Smoking marijuana and drinking

Thu, 02/07/2008 - 01:51
I was just reading on this website all of the forums about drinking and smoking cigarettes and how bad they are for you. It didnt say anything about weed and I smoke weed maybe once a week or once every two weeks and is it bad for having seizures? Also if you drink maybe two beers to three beers once a weekend is that bad?

Comments

Re: Smoking marijuana and drinking

Submitted by catsamu on Fri, 2008-04-04 - 13:16

I don't think you read what I wrote.  I didn't advocate anything except being able to ask a question here without being told to take the stupid question somewhere else.   I still advocate that.

One thing I do know is that everyone's experiences are different, and everyone's experiences are their own.  When one of us professes to know what is true for all of us, then that person stands a good chance of losing her audience.  If someone is told in no uncertain terms that something is true, and subsequently finds out that *for him or her* it is not true, then the person who hammered it over our heads as being a fact has lost credibility. 

It is a fact that marijuana is sometimes prescribed to treat epilepsy.  That means that marijuana is sometimes helpful for epilepsy.  But just like any other med, what helps one person doesn't always help another person.   Conversely, what harms one person doesn't always harm another person.  People react very differently to each drug and medication.  Some people die from an aspirin.  Some people benefit from marijuana.

It is a fact that drinking alcohol responsibly doesn't harm every person with epilepsy.  I am a person with epilepsy and it doesn't harm me.  That is true for me, but not necessarily for every person on here.   I would only ever speak for myself--I'd never tell someone that they should go out and drink because one of my hobbies is wine tasting, for example.  I'd also never tell someone to stop taking Dilantin or Tegretol and only take Keppra because that's what works for me.  My experiences and my truths are very different from yours, or anyone else who participates on this website.

Asking questions is a good thing.  That's one way to learn a variety of people's experiences.  It's a tool in decision making.  After all, if the question hadn't been asked here, the person asking it would never have learned your thoughts, experiences and opinions, correct?

However, being told that the question is stupid, and having someone else's experience being presented as the only truth out there is counterproductive to learning.  Again, that's what I advocate.  Nothing more, nothing less. 

It doesn't matter to me if you reply again or not.  Really.

Deb

I don't think you read what I wrote.  I didn't advocate anything except being able to ask a question here without being told to take the stupid question somewhere else.   I still advocate that.

One thing I do know is that everyone's experiences are different, and everyone's experiences are their own.  When one of us professes to know what is true for all of us, then that person stands a good chance of losing her audience.  If someone is told in no uncertain terms that something is true, and subsequently finds out that *for him or her* it is not true, then the person who hammered it over our heads as being a fact has lost credibility. 

It is a fact that marijuana is sometimes prescribed to treat epilepsy.  That means that marijuana is sometimes helpful for epilepsy.  But just like any other med, what helps one person doesn't always help another person.   Conversely, what harms one person doesn't always harm another person.  People react very differently to each drug and medication.  Some people die from an aspirin.  Some people benefit from marijuana.

It is a fact that drinking alcohol responsibly doesn't harm every person with epilepsy.  I am a person with epilepsy and it doesn't harm me.  That is true for me, but not necessarily for every person on here.   I would only ever speak for myself--I'd never tell someone that they should go out and drink because one of my hobbies is wine tasting, for example.  I'd also never tell someone to stop taking Dilantin or Tegretol and only take Keppra because that's what works for me.  My experiences and my truths are very different from yours, or anyone else who participates on this website.

Asking questions is a good thing.  That's one way to learn a variety of people's experiences.  It's a tool in decision making.  After all, if the question hadn't been asked here, the person asking it would never have learned your thoughts, experiences and opinions, correct?

However, being told that the question is stupid, and having someone else's experience being presented as the only truth out there is counterproductive to learning.  Again, that's what I advocate.  Nothing more, nothing less. 

It doesn't matter to me if you reply again or not.  Really.

Deb

Re: Smoking marijuana and drinking

Submitted by ttiowa on Mon, 2008-03-31 - 23:05

I have been having gm seizures for about 15 years and smoked weed for 20. I have talked to my neurologist about it and he didn't encourage me to smoke, but he didn't say "oh my god, you've got to stop right now!" either. I feel like it (smoking) helps me deal with stress, eat right, and sleep- all of which are good at keeping my seizures away. I figure if I can't get drunk and I quit smoking cigarettes (after 20 years- yeah!) then this is my one vice that I can still do. Is it good for my lungs- no, but looking at the big picture, I think I'm better off doing it then quitting.

I have been having gm seizures for about 15 years and smoked weed for 20. I have talked to my neurologist about it and he didn't encourage me to smoke, but he didn't say "oh my god, you've got to stop right now!" either. I feel like it (smoking) helps me deal with stress, eat right, and sleep- all of which are good at keeping my seizures away. I figure if I can't get drunk and I quit smoking cigarettes (after 20 years- yeah!) then this is my one vice that I can still do. Is it good for my lungs- no, but looking at the big picture, I think I'm better off doing it then quitting.

Re: Smoking marijuana and drinking

Submitted by plopdan on Fri, 2008-04-04 - 04:58

My youngest sister has M.S and it has been proven to help those who suffer from that condition.  Now this would'nt have come to light because of peoples differing views especially those who do not suffer from it. As for epilepsy the washing is still on the line there is no real proof one way or the other. As for me I tried it twice and both times I just twitched a lot.  As for other illicit drugs what ever your poison is please keep it home and don't try and pull inpressionable people down with you.

Every one has a right to be heard with in reason.

plopdan u.k

My youngest sister has M.S and it has been proven to help those who suffer from that condition.  Now this would'nt have come to light because of peoples differing views especially those who do not suffer from it. As for epilepsy the washing is still on the line there is no real proof one way or the other. As for me I tried it twice and both times I just twitched a lot.  As for other illicit drugs what ever your poison is please keep it home and don't try and pull inpressionable people down with you.

Every one has a right to be heard with in reason.

plopdan u.k

Sign Up for Emails

Stay up to date with the latest epilepsy news, stories from the community, and more.