Community Forum Archive
The Epilepsy Community Forums are closed, and the information is archived. The content in this section may not be current or apply to all situations. In addition, forum questions and responses include information and content that has been generated by epilepsy community members. This content is not moderated. The information on these pages should not be substituted for medical advice from a healthcare provider. Experiences with epilepsy can vary greatly on an individual basis. Please contact your doctor or medical team if you have any questions about your situation. For more information, learn about epilepsy or visit our resources section.
For those who have or know about pseudoseizures
Fri, 11/05/2010 - 19:00Comments
Re: For those who have or know about pseudoseizures
Submitted by zealot on Sat, 2010-11-06 - 22:39
Marty,
I am having difficulty with her language. That is a huge problem. She does have epilepsy and I know from personal exerience that linquistic skills are one of the casualties. Still, she makes emphatic statements as if speaking from expertise and then expresses ignorance. It is troubling.
I don't believe in "shoulds." I believe MJ may be very frightened for the child and it may be possible that she feels so bad about her own epilepsy that she desperately hopes that the same fate is not in store for the child. Unfortunately, the PNES hokum is a worse fate than epilepsy.
The child is being punished for being sick. She is told that she can't watch TV. Eat "junk." Play video games. All the good kid stuff. She's still having seizures even though she's being punished for them. So now they want to give her sugar pills. Huh.
It is possible that the child has a medical condition other than epilepsy that is causing her seizures. I've said this before: "not epilepsy" is vast, uncharted territory. The seizures are real. The cause is unknown. PNES is a label for "I'm too stupid, cheap, or lazy to figure it out so I'll blame the patient." The Drs. rallying cry.
I said this before too: a couple of generations ago Drs. were telling patients with diabetes to go home because it was "all in their heads." Well, guess what. Epilepsy is. That's where our brains are.
The best advice I can give is to tell the parents to take their daughter to a different neurologist. The kid's not faking if punishment didn't make her "pseudo seizures" go away. And faking, by the way is not "PNES."
There is absolutely no evidence that aversive conditioning could be effective in treating PNES as it is associated with PTSD and trauma because of the work done in the 1890s by Pierre Janet. In fact, punishing an already traumatised person for their trauma symptoms only causes more trauma and exacerbation of symptoms. One would have hoped that we'd come a long way since then, but apparently, not.
Baruch Hashem. Hoshia na.
Devorah Zealot Soodak http://psychout.typepad.com/ the zealot needs help! Please read my blog. Thanks.
Marty,
I am having difficulty with her language. That is a huge problem. She does have epilepsy and I know from personal exerience that linquistic skills are one of the casualties. Still, she makes emphatic statements as if speaking from expertise and then expresses ignorance. It is troubling.
I don't believe in "shoulds." I believe MJ may be very frightened for the child and it may be possible that she feels so bad about her own epilepsy that she desperately hopes that the same fate is not in store for the child. Unfortunately, the PNES hokum is a worse fate than epilepsy.
The child is being punished for being sick. She is told that she can't watch TV. Eat "junk." Play video games. All the good kid stuff. She's still having seizures even though she's being punished for them. So now they want to give her sugar pills. Huh.
It is possible that the child has a medical condition other than epilepsy that is causing her seizures. I've said this before: "not epilepsy" is vast, uncharted territory. The seizures are real. The cause is unknown. PNES is a label for "I'm too stupid, cheap, or lazy to figure it out so I'll blame the patient." The Drs. rallying cry.
I said this before too: a couple of generations ago Drs. were telling patients with diabetes to go home because it was "all in their heads." Well, guess what. Epilepsy is. That's where our brains are.
The best advice I can give is to tell the parents to take their daughter to a different neurologist. The kid's not faking if punishment didn't make her "pseudo seizures" go away. And faking, by the way is not "PNES."
There is absolutely no evidence that aversive conditioning could be effective in treating PNES as it is associated with PTSD and trauma because of the work done in the 1890s by Pierre Janet. In fact, punishing an already traumatised person for their trauma symptoms only causes more trauma and exacerbation of symptoms. One would have hoped that we'd come a long way since then, but apparently, not.
Baruch Hashem. Hoshia na.
Devorah Zealot Soodak http://psychout.typepad.com/ the zealot needs help! Please read my blog. Thanks.
Re: For those who have or know about pseudoseizures
Submitted by thebettles on Sat, 2010-11-06 - 21:28
Hi again Deborah,
I appreciate you bringing my attention again to the exact phrasing MJ used to attempt to describe the situation. I imagine you would describe this situation very differently if it were happening to you; a young adult who you are very close to starts showing signs of possibly having seizures or PNES. Possibly it is the wording of the post that is getting in the way here, and possibly MJ cares very deeply for this child, regardless of describing the situation and using language which to you sounds as though the exact opposite were true.
Are you leaving any room here for any of these possibilities or have you already come to the conclusion that this young child is in for a life of pain and misery and misunderstanding, a life of struggle and hardship.
Do you have the patience to let the mud settle?
You are incredibly insightful, Deborah, and might be tremendously helpful in this situation. This requires not being personally offended by MJ. Can you get there? Can you be helpful even though you see so much ignorance and disdain in this supposed "role model"?
Can you be helpful specifically because of the lapses in qualities you feel MJ should have?
You seem to have an affinity for young adults, telling them to read your blog, if they can "handle it"...
What might be some helpful suggestions for ensuring this young adult gets the care she needs?
much love to all,
marty
Hi again Deborah,
I appreciate you bringing my attention again to the exact phrasing MJ used to attempt to describe the situation. I imagine you would describe this situation very differently if it were happening to you; a young adult who you are very close to starts showing signs of possibly having seizures or PNES. Possibly it is the wording of the post that is getting in the way here, and possibly MJ cares very deeply for this child, regardless of describing the situation and using language which to you sounds as though the exact opposite were true.
Are you leaving any room here for any of these possibilities or have you already come to the conclusion that this young child is in for a life of pain and misery and misunderstanding, a life of struggle and hardship.
Do you have the patience to let the mud settle?
You are incredibly insightful, Deborah, and might be tremendously helpful in this situation. This requires not being personally offended by MJ. Can you get there? Can you be helpful even though you see so much ignorance and disdain in this supposed "role model"?
Can you be helpful specifically because of the lapses in qualities you feel MJ should have?
You seem to have an affinity for young adults, telling them to read your blog, if they can "handle it"...
What might be some helpful suggestions for ensuring this young adult gets the care she needs?
much love to all,
marty