Community Forum Archive

The Epilepsy Community Forums are closed, and the information is archived. The content in this section may not be current or apply to all situations. In addition, forum questions and responses include information and content that has been generated by epilepsy community members. This content is not moderated. The information on these pages should not be substituted for medical advice from a healthcare provider. Experiences with epilepsy can vary greatly on an individual basis. Please contact your doctor or medical team if you have any questions about your situation. For more information, learn about epilepsy or visit our resources section.

Simple Partial Seizures v. BiPolar Disorder

Wed, 01/05/2005 - 09:13
This may sound strange, but I really need the input. My Nephew was recently diagnosed with BiPolar Disorder. The "Diagnosis" from what I understand was made simply from descriptions of his behavior. No types of tests. I'm concerned since there is a family history of Epilepsy and since his behavior could also be fit into the classification of Simple Partial Seizures -"Psychic seizures". Has anyone heard of or experienced one of these conditions being mis-diagnosed as the other? My sister will only investigate the possibility if I can show her that it has happened to someone else. I don't want to see my nephew suffer for hi mother's stubbornness. Or, am I totally off base? If I'm wrong I'll be glad to know that too.

Comments

RE: RE: Simple Partial Seizures v. BiPolar Disorder

Submitted by ruppell on Wed, 2005-01-05 - 09:13

My significant other has been diagnosed and treated for Bipolar, Schizophrenia, and a host of other psychological problems for years.  On 27 Oct 04 he had two grand-mal seizures within just under an hour.  He spent most of the morning seizing before anyone knew what was going on.  The doc says he has Epilepsy.  He starts off with simple partials - these are anything from "precognitive" or "telepathic" type feelings, hallucinations - visual, sounds and/or smells, massive mood swings - from "psychotic happiness" to absolute suicidal with lots of incidents of homicidal behavior.  He never accepted the diagnoses of the mental problems, he said they never "fit".  I thought it was just because everyone is different and no explanation can "fit" perfectly.  But, now that we've been told epilepsy, he accepts the diagnosis more readily (HATES the fact, but accepts the possibility).  He's an extremely logical person and he says this "makes sense". 

My significant other has been diagnosed and treated for Bipolar, Schizophrenia, and a host of other psychological problems for years.  On 27 Oct 04 he had two grand-mal seizures within just under an hour.  He spent most of the morning seizing before anyone knew what was going on.  The doc says he has Epilepsy.  He starts off with simple partials - these are anything from "precognitive" or "telepathic" type feelings, hallucinations - visual, sounds and/or smells, massive mood swings - from "psychotic happiness" to absolute suicidal with lots of incidents of homicidal behavior.  He never accepted the diagnoses of the mental problems, he said they never "fit".  I thought it was just because everyone is different and no explanation can "fit" perfectly.  But, now that we've been told epilepsy, he accepts the diagnosis more readily (HATES the fact, but accepts the possibility).  He's an extremely logical person and he says this "makes sense". 

RE: RE: RE: Simple Partial Seizures v. BiPolar Disorder

Submitted by Elizabeth4 on Wed, 2005-04-20 - 20:30
Hi,My boyfriend has epile^psy i am not sure what kind but he has then 2-3 per month and within the last year he goes through a period when he looks spaced talks crazy and is super happy and does not listen to me like in a little happy land or total opposite and very mean and violente i have to sit in font of door so he does not get out or get out myself.   Could this be a seizure without shaking just mental does that even exsist. or is it schyzophrenia...what do you think..

RE: RE: Simple Partial Seizures v. BiPolar Disorder

Submitted by Yakota on Sat, 2005-04-16 - 15:30
Hi boddhisattva? Have you had eegs done to rule out the possiblity of epilepsy? I was grossly misdiagnosed with psychological problems instead of epilesy. I have temporal lobe epilepsy. But for seven years I was told that I had psychological problems, given several psychiatric diagnoses, and treated with psych drugs. The psych drugs induced me to psychosis. The drugs also induced me to seizure to the point of near death. In March of 2003 I underwent emergency surgery and received the vns. It has been 25 months since I stopped taking the psych drugs. I know what you mean about the "lables" that you aquire with a psychiatric diagnoses. It is horrible. You never loose them. I believe the psychiatrists receive better fiancial kickbacks from the pharmacutical companies than the neurologists. A prescription of Seroquel is more expensive than a script for dilantin. Seroquel costs more to make? It is a vicious cycle. If you can make a person drug dependant for life then you have a secure investment! If the person is a psychiatric patient the profits are gained through many different sources. The list of those who profit from one patient are as follows; the insurance companies, primary care and MD. physicians, attending psychiatrist, social worker or counselor, the pharmacutical companies, hospitals or clinics, (including inpatient and outpatient treatment centers,) and add a neurologist to the list. Since most of the drugs prescribed by psychiatrists lower the threshold for seizure many pateints who have never had need to see a neurologist will need one. I have to question the motive behind what moves the medical community, (and now a possible nation wide legislative act,) to psychologically test and medicate the masses. It couldn't be for financial profit could it? Maybe it is for control? I am 44. The misdiagnoses that I lived through happened after my brain was fully developed. If you feed a five year old mood stabalizers for seven years, what will happen to the child's brain when as a teenager the mood stabalizers are discontinued? The neurons inside of the kid's brain will start to fire at unrecognizable patterns. Poor kid. As his brain was cognitively developing the neurons learned to fire off under the instruction of the mood stabalizer. I almost lost my life (and did loose my mind,) from a psychiatric misdiagnosis. It is appauling that this issue is just gaining the exposure it derserves. It is a bad situation. I hope we don't ever live to see the day when manditory psychological testing is implimented. People make mistakes. It happened to me!!! I hope this has been helpful. Yakota.

Sign Up for Emails

Stay up to date with the latest epilepsy news, stories from the community, and more.