Place Your Advertisement Here
All ad revenues support the mission of the Epilepsy Therapy Project
 
UPDATED: Thu, 11/08/2007 - 12:04am

  • Epilepsy First Aid
  • Seizure Medication
  • Videos
  • Seizure Diary
  • Find a Doctor
  • Epilepsy Centers
  • Clinical Trials
  • Event Calendar

Place Your Advertisement Here
All ad revenues support the mission
of the Epilepsy Therapy Project

Results

A randomized study of the effectiveness of epilepsy surgery

In the past, epilepsy surgery was often been regarded as an unsafe, expensive "last resort" for patients who continued to have uncontrolled seizures after being treated with medication for many years. A problem of most studies of epilepsy surgery was that they just reported on the outcomes of patients who underwent operations, a carefully selected group, without measuring how a comparable group of patients would fare if continued on medication alone. This kind of non-randomized study is likely to overestimate benefits and underestimate harm.

An important study was reported at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Neurology in May 2001, Dr. Samuel Wiebe of the University of Western Ontario presented the results of a randomized study comparing surgery to treatment with medication in 80 patients with difficult-to-control temporal lobe epilepsy. The randomized structure of this study was possible because patients at the hospital where Dr. Wiebe and his colleagues practice are routinely placed on a 1-year waiting list before undergoing surgery. For the purposes of the study, half of the study group (40 patients) received this standard treatment. During the year they spent on the waiting list, these 40 patients took medications prescribed by skilled epileptologists. The other 40 patients underwent immediate presurgical evaluation and surgery.

After 1 year, 58% of the patients who had undergone surgery had not experienced a complex partial seizure (a seizure that impairs consciousness), and 38% had not experienced any seizures, including auras. In contrast, only 8% of the patients treated with medication were free of complex partial seizures, and 3% had no seizures. For the patients treated with surgery who continued to have some seizures, they were less frequent than in the other group, but the severity was similar.

The quality of life of the patients treated with surgery was judged to be significantly better than for the other patients. Of the patients who had surgery, 55% were working or studying, versus 36% in the other group. Negative effects of surgery included a decline in memory in a small number of patients and a defect in a small part of their visual field in 55%.

Although standard statistical analysis of the results of this study showed surgery to be significantly better with regard to seizure control and quality of life, some caution about the interpretation of the results was advised by Dr. Wiebe and by Dr. Susan Spencer of Yale University, who was the "Discussant" for this presentation. Both of them noted that a longer follow-up period would be valuable, especially with regard to measuring quality of life. Some other studies of epilepsy surgery that have followed patients for longer periods have found that some patients who are initially seizure-free may experience seizures later, and their quality-of-life scores may worsen somewhat, especially if they continue to experience seizures.

Nevertheless, Dr. Wiebe concluded that surgery is an effective treatment for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy when medication fails to control seizures. Although care is certainly necessary in choosing which patients are likely to benefit from surgery, physicians and insurers should not persist with unsuccessful medical treatment for many years or decades before recommending surgery, as has often been the practice.

The same study was subsequently published in the New England Journal of Medicine: Wiebe S, Blume WT, Girvin JP, Eliasziw M; Effectiveness and Efficiency of Surgery for Temporal Lobe Epilepsy Study Group. A randomized, controlled trial of surgery for temporal-lobe epilepsy. N Engl J Med 2001 345:311-8.

Topic Editor: Howard L. Weiner, M.D.
Last Reviewed:3/8/04


Welcome to the Wiki. This space is created for epilepsy.com members to share their own experiences and expertise to help refine and expand the discussion around important topics.

No members have yet contributed to this topic. If you are not yet an epilepsy.com member, register today to get started on this Wiki topic and the many other advantages of being a member. If you are a member and wish to be the first to edit this Wiki topic, please make sure to login, then click on the orange "Start Wiki" button at the top of this page. Or, learn more about Wikis.


Turn the page on your treatment by starting your Epilepsy Diary today.

Keeping a daily record of your seizures can help you and your doctor better understand and treat your epilepsy.

Open my epiCom Diary


Title Posted
How long do you wait?  
ValNewLife
View all Forums

Title Posted
Ecstatic Seizures  
victoria.w
Embarrassed  
kyrissa
8 year old with rolandic epilepsy  
robin510
Vitamin B6  
eanj
Simple Partials Seizures-What Are Yours Like & Duration?  
Maria7
I Have Epilepsy and I Hate My Life...  
1nevermore
Will my car insurance rates go up in a single car accident?  
bakerdvd
Switching to Topamax from Depakote ER.. Advice?  
jessicarenee
A Scary Doctor  
snoodle
VNS  
maryem
View all Forums

Title Page Views
my.epilepsy.com Updates  
epi_help
topamax and weight loss  
alexia mom
kepra  
brian mattingly
Possible cure for absence seizures  
pdl1
Epilepsy and marijuana  
cjad234
Sexual Side Effects  
George R
How exactly do aura's feel  
WendyBendy
MEDICAL ALERT I.D.'s  
picnupthepcs
Over 40 Different Types Of Seizures - Revised  
spiz
electrical shock in head?  
Maggie
View all Forums

Title Posted
what should i do?  
BiGirl101297
View all Blogs

Title Posted
Heck of a day  
4mygirl2
The Last Voice  
cindy thacher
Ugg boots  
shirts
UGG lays its charm  
shirts
UGG lays its charm  
shirts
29 years old, had seizures since I was 8.  
dkalra
Stroll for Epilepsy Awareness  
bookworm03
Epilepsy Advocacy  
krjohnson
Hello Again, catching up!  
chandagunn
PowerPoint to Youtube  
dwightgenius
View all Blogs

Title Page Views
Inspirational Quote - My Own Personal Inner Thoughts  
Butterflygrl
my partial complex seizures  
Zanna1211
Topomax... The Dreaded.........  
Dr Jason
Brain Zaps, tics & twitches  
JudiS
side effects of phenobarb.  
pksmom
Feeling Sick  
JBJ1984
How can you tell if a sleep seizure happens?  
epl_controller
Tegretol XR and ANXIETY meds  
Butterflygrl
TYLENOL, AEDs & SEIZURES  
cmscribbles
Nonepileptic "Events" vs. "Seizures"  
teft
View all Blogs

Title Posted
Project Uplift  
tamliniscute
SEIZURE FREE  
gracie9933
EPILEPSY SUPPORT GROUP NORTH CAROLINA  
Roxanne D
Community Feedback on Proposed New epilepsy.com Feature  
kdredske
Parent with Child with Epilepsy,Dystonia, and Autism  
TashaCole
RX outreach Program  
mw
Fun and Games  
phylisfjohnson
Epilepsy and Memory Loss??  
lindseygthatsme
Epileptic Postictal Psychosis  
Bravedefender
Northern California Volunteers  
cannemo73
View all Groups

Title Posted
My Meningioma Story  
Maria7
My First time  
SteveDaw
My Epilepsy  
amberbrady5384
The crazy spiritual journey that is a seizure.  
zeus1223
29 years old; epilepsy since I was 8.  
dkalra
my experience with epilepsy  
Sabia
Family with Epilepsy  
thunley
My Story Of How I Was Diagnosed With Epilepsy.  
bass_babyx
Lorrelei71  
Lorrelei71
i guess this is my life now.  
RhiannonElizabeth
View all Stories

Place Your Advertisement Here
All ad revenues support the mission
of the Epilepsy Therapy Project